(up to 2020)
Henry Adam: 1 win
- 2003–04, The People Next Door, Traverse Theatre Company
Davey Anderson: 1 win
- 2008–09, Liar, TAG, Best Show for Children and Young People
Peter Arnott: 3 wins
- 2017–18, The Monarch of the Glen, Pitlochry Festival Theatre
- 2019–20, The Signalman, A Play, a Pie and a Pint
- 2019–20, The Signalman, A Play, a Pie and a Pint, Best Production
Torben Betts: 1 win
- 2006–07, The Unconquered, Stellar Quines
Rob Drummond: 3 wins
- 2009–10, Mr Write, National Theatre of Scotland, Best Show for Children and Young People
- 2012–13, Quiz Show, Traverse Theatre Company
- 2015–16, Uncanny Valley, Borderline Theatre in co-production with the Gaiety Theatre, commissioned by Edinburgh International Science Festival working in partnership with Imaginate, Best Show for Children and Young People, Won
David Greig: 2 wins
- 2002–03, Outlying Islands, Traverse Theatre Company
- 2006–07, Gobbo, National Theatre of Scotland, Best Show for Children and Young People
Chris Hannan: 1 win
- 2010–11, The Three Musketeers and the Princess of Spain, Traverse Theatre Company
Zinnie Harris: 1 win
- 2015–16, This Restless House, Citizens Theatre and National Theatre of Scotland, won
David Harrower: 2 wins
- 2005–06, Blackbird, Edinburgh International Festival
- 2013–14, Ciara. Traverse Theatre Company
Kieran Hurley: 2 wins
- 2011–12, BEATS, The Arches
- 2016–17, Heads Up, Kieran Hurley and Show and Tell
David Ireland: 1 win
- 2018–19, Ulster American, Traverse Theatre Company
Marin McCormick: 1 win
- 2014–15, Squash, A Play, a Pie and a Pint/Traverse
Anthony Neilson: 1 win
- 2004–05, The Wonderful World of Dissocia, Edinburgh International Festival
Ursula Rani Sama: 1 win
- 2009–10, The Dark Things, Traverse Theatre Company
Simon Stephens: 1 win
- 2008–09, Pornography, Traverse Theatre Company
Alan Wilkins: 1 win
- 2007–08, Carthage Must Be Destroyed, Traverse Theatre Company