(up to 2020)
Seylan Baxter: 1 win
- 2008–09, The Lasses O, Rowan Tree Theatre
Hilary Brooks: 2 wins
- 2010–11, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, Dundee Rep Theatre
- 2012–13, Irving Berlin’s White Christmas: The Musical, Pitlochry Festival Theatre
Tyler Collins: 1 win
- 2014–15, Last Dream (On Earth), Kai Fischer/NTS/Tron
Paddy Cunneen: 2 wins
- 2003–04, Twelfth Night, Dundee Rep Theatre
- 2011–12, King Lear, Citizens Theatre Company
James Fortune: 1 win
- 2013–14, The Beautiful Cosmos of Ivor Cutler, Vanishing Point
Scott Gilmour: 1 win
- 2018–19, My Left Right Foot – The Musical, Birds of Paradise and the National Theatre of Scotland, Won
Matthias Hermann: 1 win
- 2019–2020, Thank You Very Much, Manchester International Festival and National Theatre of Scotland
Oğuz Kaplangı: 1 nomination, inc 1 win
- 2017–18, Rhinoceros, Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh
Lillias Kinsman-Blake: 1 win
- 2008–09, The Lasses O, Rowan Tree Theatre
Andrew Kirkby: 1 win
- 2013–14, The Beautiful Cosmos of Ivor Cutler, Vanishing Point
Martin Lowe: 1 win
- 2015–16, Our Ladies of Perpetual Succour, National Theatre of Scotland and Live Theatre
Claire McKenzie: 1 win
- 2018–19, My Left Right Foot – The Musical, Birds of Paradise and the National Theatre of Scotland, Won
Alasdair Macrae: 3 wins
- 2007–08, Subway, Vanishing Point
- 2009–10, The Government Inspector, Communicado
- 2010–11, The Strange Undoing of Prudencia Hart, National Theatre of Scotland
Mark Melville: 1 win
- 2013–14, The Beautiful Cosmos of Ivor Cutler, Vanishing Point
Pippa Murphy: 1 win
- 2016–17, Wind Resistance, Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh and Edinburgh International Festival
Hugh Nankivell: 1 win
- 2005–06, Home: Shetland, National Theatre of Scotland
Rachel Newton: 1 win
- 2008–09, The Lasses O, Rowan Tree Theatre
Matt Padden: 1 win
- 2014–15, Last Dream (On Earth), Kai Fischer/NTS/Tron
Robert Pettigrew: 1 win
- 2006–07, Man of La Mancha, Royal Lyceum Theatre
Philip Pinsky: 1 win
- 2004–05, Fierce, Grid Iron
Karine Polwart: 1 win
- 2016–17, Wind Resistance, Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh and Edinburgh International Festival
Ben Seal: 1 win
- 2016–17, Wind Resistance, Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh and Edinburgh International Festival
Richard Thomas: 1 win
- 2018–19, My Left Right Foot – The Musical, Birds of Paradise and the National Theatre of Scotland, Won
Gameli Tordzro: 1 win
- 2014–15, Last Dream (On Earth), Kai Fischer/NTS/Tron
Mike Walker: 1 win
- 2015–16, Our Ladies of Perpetual Succour, National Theatre of Scotland and Live Theatre
Mark Whyles: 1 win
- 2016–17, Wind Resistance, Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh and Edinburgh International Festival