(up to 2020)
Adam Best: 1 win
- 2013–14, Crime and Punishment, Citizens Theatre Company
John Bett: 1 win
- 2003–04 Scenes From an Execution, Dundee Rep Theatre
David Birrell: 1 win
- 2010–11 Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, Dundee Rep Theatre, Won
Liam Brennan: 1 win
- 2005–06 Tales from Hollywood, Perth Theatre
Stephen Clyde: 1 win
- 2011–12 A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Bard in the Botanics
Alan Cumming: 1 win
- 2012–13, Macbeth, National Theatre of Scotland
Keith Fleming: 1 win
- 2007–08 Peer Gynt, National Theatre of Scotland
Sandy Grierson: 2 wins
- 2006–07 Fergus Lamont, Communicado
- 2015–16, Lanark: A Life in Three Acts, Citizens Theatre and the Edinburgh International Festival in association with Graham Eatough and Sorcha Dallas.
Robert Jack: 1 win
- 2017–18, Rhinoceros, Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh
John Kazek: 1 win
- 2003–04 Pleasure and Pain, Citizens Theatre Company
Kevin Lennon: 1 win
- 2009–10 The Elephant Man, Dundee Rep Ensemble
Billy Mack: 1 win
- 2016–17, Death of a Salesman, Dundee Rep Ensemble
Tom McGovern: 1 win
- 2019–2020, The Signalman, A Play, a Pie and a Pint in association with the Traverse Theatre
John Michie: 1 win
- 2018–19, The Mack, A Play, a Pie and a Pint
Gerry Mulgrew: 1 win
- 2007–08 Peer Gynt, National Theatre of Scotland
Grant O’Rourke: 1 win
- 2014–15, The Venetian Twins, Royal Lyceum
David Tennant: 1 win
- 2004–05 Look Back in Anger, Royal Lyceum Theatre
Matthew Zajac: 1 win
- 2008–09 The Tailor of Inverness, Dogstar Theatre Company